Case Note on Arnsberg Local Court, 1 July 2026 – 42 C 434/23
Abuse of the Right of Access – Brillen Rottler
Under what circumstances may a company refuse even an initial access request under Article 15 GDPR on grounds of abuse of rights? In the “Brillen Rottler” case, Arnsberg Local Court applies the CJEU’s criteria to an access request by a newsletter subscriber. This case note examines the indicators suggesting that an access request is deliberately intended to create the conditions for a compensation claim. It also considers the implications for compensation under Article 82 GDPR and the requirements for informing data subjects of their available remedies when access is refused. Finally, it explores how requests for preliminary rulings to the CJEU can contribute to the efficient handling of data protection cases before local courts.
Read the full article →